Should I Take My Personal Injury Case to Court or Settle?

by | Dec 20, 2023 | Personal Injury |

When you’re facing the aftermath of a personal injury, the question of whether your case will end up in court or reach a settlement is undoubtedly on your mind. The concerns and uncertainties that come with pursuing justice for the harm you’ve suffered can weigh heavily on you.

In this blog, we’ll guide you through the decision-making process, shedding light on the factors to consider in determining whether to pursue a personal injury claim in court or resolve it outside the courthouse.

What factors into the decision to go to court or settle a case?

Before you file a lawsuit, you should work with an experienced personal injury attorney to assess your position, including the strengths and weaknesses of your case.

Here are some key things to think about during this decision-making process.

  • How strong is your evidence? If the evidence strongly supports your claims, pursuing litigation may be a strategic move to secure a favorable judgment. If you don’t have much evidence or the evidence you have isn’t convincing, you may feel more confident pursuing a settlement.
  • How long do you want to wait to resolve the case? Trials can take a long time, and the longer they go on, the more they can cost. As a client, you may want to consider the time and financial commitments associated with litigation. Settling out of court can offer a more expedited resolution, sparing you from extended legal proceedings and associated expenses.
  • How much risk are you willing to take? Nothing is certain in trial. You may prefer to settle your case if you want to minimize uncertainties and secure a predictable outcome.
  • What insurance coverage, if any, do you have? If you have favorable insurance coverage, it may make sense to pursue a trial. However, insurance companies often prefer settlements to manage costs, and negotiating a settlement can help you get paid faster.

What are the benefits of going to court?

Going to court in a personal injury case can have certain benefits, depending on the circumstances of your case. Here are some potential advantages of pursuing litigation in a personal injury claim:

  • Seeking justice: Going to court provides an avenue for holding the responsible party accountable for the injuries sustained. A court trial allows for a thorough examination of the facts and determination of legal liability.
  • Full compensation: A court trial can result in an award of fair compensation for the damages suffered, including medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other losses. The court ensures that the compensation aligns with the extent of the harm caused.
  • Establishing precedent: The court’s decision can establish legal precedent, influencing similar cases in the future. This can contribute to the development of personal injury law and provide guidance for subsequent disputes.
  • Access to information: The formal discovery process in court allows both parties to gather evidence, depose witnesses, and obtain information that might not be readily available during pretrial negotiations. This can be valuable in building a robust case.
  • Enforceable judgment: A court judgment is legally binding and enforceable. If the liable party fails to comply with the court’s decision, you can pursue legal remedies to ensure the judgment is honored.

While these benefits exist, it’s crucial to acknowledge that litigation also comes with potential drawbacks, including time, cost, and the inherent uncertainty of court decisions.

What are the benefits of an out-of-court settlement?

If you’re on the fence about whether to go to court or settle, these benefits may tip the scale in favor of settlement.

  • Confidentiality: Your privacy matters. Settlements offer a confidential resolution, keeping sensitive information away from the public eye.
  • Faster resolution: Settling out of court gives you quicker closure on a painful event and can reduce the stress associated with prolonged legal battles.
  • Lower costs: A settlement can significantly reduce legal fees and other expenses, ensuring a more cost-effective solution for you.

What’s the right choice for you?

As you embark on the journey to seek justice for your personal injury, understanding the dynamics of courtroom battles versus settlements is crucial. Your decision will be influenced by the strength of your case, the associated costs and time commitments, your risk tolerance, and the presence of insurance coverage.

The experienced personal injury attorneys at Hunter & Everage are committed to guiding you through this difficult process. We’ll help you understand the best strategy for your circumstances and help you design the right strategy to increase your chances of recovery.

Get in touch with our personal injury attorneys in Charlotte, Montgomery, and Richmond today.

The Importance Of A Local Attorney